Catering in Amagansett, NY
Your Event, Our Kitchen, Zero Stress
Hear from Our Customers
Amagansett Event Catering Services
You know the feeling. You spend weeks planning the perfect event, then spend the entire time in the kitchen while your guests have all the fun. That changes now.
When you choose Brendel’s for your Amagansett catering, you’re not just getting food delivered. You’re getting a full-service team that handles everything from setup to cleanup. We bring the grills, the utensils, the staff, and the expertise directly to your location.
Your job becomes simple: show up and enjoy. Your guests get fresh, locally-sourced food prepared on-site. You get to actually be present at your own celebration.
Amagansett's Premier Catering Company
We’ve been serving the Amagansett community for years, but we’re not your typical bagel shop. While our kettle-cooked bagels built our reputation, our catering services have made us Suffolk County’s go-to choice for events that matter.
We understand Amagansett’s unique character. This community values quality, authenticity, and supporting local businesses. That’s exactly what we deliver – fresh ingredients from Long Island farms, traditional preparation methods, and the kind of personal service that only comes from being part of the community.
Whether you’re hosting corporate executives at a beachfront property or celebrating a family milestone in your backyard, we know what works in Amagansett.
How Our Catering Process Works
First, we talk. Call 1-866-CATERING and we’ll discuss your event, guest count, dietary needs, and location. No generic packages – we create a menu that fits your specific situation.
Next, we plan. We handle all the logistics: timing, equipment needs, staff requirements, and setup details. You approve the final plan and we take care of the rest.
On event day, we arrive early to set up everything. Our team brings all necessary equipment, from grills to serving utensils. We cook fresh on-site, serve your guests professionally, and handle complete cleanup afterward. You focus on hosting, we handle everything else.
Ready to get started?
Complete Amagansett Catering Services
Our catering goes far beyond food delivery. We’re talking full-service event support designed specifically for Amagansett’s diverse event needs.
For BBQ events, we bring everything: grills, gas, utensils, serving equipment, and professional grillmasters who cook on-site. Fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy chicken, fresh corn, and homemade sides prepared exactly how you want them. We even provide wait staff if you need extra service coverage.
Breakfast and lunch catering features our signature kettle-cooked bagels, fresh cream cheeses, and gourmet sandwiches. Italian catering brings authentic flavors with locally-sourced ingredients. Dessert services round out any celebration perfectly.
The Amagansett advantage means we understand your venue challenges, from beachfront logistics to private estate requirements. We’ve catered events across Suffolk County and know how to adapt our service to any location.
How far in advance should I book catering for my Amagansett event?
For most events, two weeks notice gives us plenty of time to plan properly and source the freshest local ingredients. However, we can often accommodate shorter timeframes depending on your event size and menu requirements.
Peak seasons like summer in the Hamptons and major holidays typically book faster, so earlier is always better. For large events over 100 people or specialty requests like our full BBQ service, we recommend booking 3-4 weeks ahead.
Call us as soon as you have your date confirmed. We’ll lock in your reservation and work with you on menu details as your plans develop.
Do you provide catering equipment and staff for outdoor Amagansett events?
Absolutely. Our full-service approach means we bring everything needed for successful outdoor catering, whether you’re hosting at a beachfront property, backyard, or public venue in Amagansett.
For BBQ catering, we provide grills, gas, all cooking utensils, serving equipment, plates, napkins, and professional grillmasters who handle all food preparation on-site. We also offer optional wait staff to ensure your guests are properly attended to throughout the event.
Setup and cleanup are completely handled by our team. We arrive early to prepare everything and stay until your space is clean and restored. You won’t lift a finger except to enjoy your own event.
What types of dietary restrictions can you accommodate in your catering menus?
We work with virtually any dietary requirement because we prepare most items fresh and can modify recipes as needed. Common accommodations include vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and various food allergies.
Our breakfast catering easily adapts to dietary needs with gluten-free bagel options, dairy-free spreads, and fresh fruit selections. BBQ menus can include grilled vegetables, alternative proteins, and sides that meet specific requirements.
During menu planning, we’ll discuss all dietary needs upfront and create solutions that ensure every guest has delicious options. Our locally-sourced ingredients also mean we can often provide fresher, cleaner alternatives to processed foods.
How does pricing work for catering services in Amagansett?
Pricing depends on several factors: guest count, menu selections, service level, and event location logistics. We provide detailed quotes after understanding your specific needs rather than using generic per-person rates.
Our breakfast and lunch packages typically offer the most value, while specialty services like full BBQ catering with staff and equipment represent premium pricing for premium service. We’re transparent about all costs upfront, including any travel fees for Amagansett locations.
Most clients find our pricing competitive when they factor in the complete service level – food, equipment, staff, setup, and cleanup all included. Call 1-866-CATERING for a detailed quote based on your specific event requirements.
Can you cater events at private homes and beaches in Amagansett?
Yes, we specialize in catering at private locations throughout Amagansett, including residential properties, beachfront venues, and estate locations. Our mobile service model is designed specifically for off-premise events.
We’re experienced with the unique logistics of Amagansett locations, from beach access considerations to private property requirements. Our team knows how to work within various venue restrictions while still delivering full-service catering.
Beach events are particularly popular for our BBQ catering service. We handle all equipment transport, setup in sandy conditions, and proper cleanup that respects Amagansett’s beautiful natural environment. Just provide the location and guest count – we handle the rest.
What makes Brendel's different from other catering companies serving Amagansett?
Two things set us apart: our local community connection and our complete service approach. We’re not just a catering company that happens to serve Amagansett – we’re part of the Suffolk County community with multiple Long Island locations.
This means we understand local tastes, source from area farms, and know the logistical challenges of different venue types in the region. Our kettle-cooked bagel heritage also brings authentic food preparation methods that many catering companies can’t match.
Most importantly, we provide truly full-service catering. When we say we handle setup, cooking, and cleanup, we mean it completely. You’re not coordinating multiple vendors or managing any food service details. One call to 1-866-CATERING covers everything your event needs.
Local Resources