Catering in Atlantic Beach, NY
Your Event Stress Just Disappeared
Hear from Our Customers
Atlantic Beach Catering Services
You know that moment when your guests stop talking and start eating? That’s what happens when you serve food that’s actually worth the conversation pause.
We use the freshest ingredients, many locally sourced, and prepare all dishes fresh for your event. No reheated trays or generic catering platters. Your guests taste the difference between food that was made for your event versus food that was made for anyone’s event.
We handle all the setup, cooking, and cleanup so you can mix and mingle with your guests instead of standing behind a hot barbecue. You hired a caterer to make your life easier, not to give you more tasks to manage.
Brendels Bagels Atlantic Beach
Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery serves the freshest homemade bagels, bialys, flagels, and cream cheeses in Nassau County, but we’re also one of the leading catering companies in the area. We’re Atlantic Beach’s go-to breakfast café and full-service caterer.
What sets us apart isn’t just our traditional kettle-cooking method that creates bagels with that perfect chewy interior and crispy exterior. It’s our understanding that when you’re hosting an event in Atlantic Beach, you need more than just good food—you need a partner who gets the local expectations.
Corporate spending on catered events is up, with more businesses investing in product launches and employee appreciation meals. We’ve been serving Long Island’s corporate and family events long enough to know exactly what works.
Atlantic Beach Catering Process
First, we talk through your event. Not just headcount and budget, but what you’re actually trying to accomplish. Corporate breakfast meeting? Family celebration? Backyard BBQ? Each requires a different approach, and we’ve done them all.
We work with you to custom-craft a catering menu that will WOW every palate at your party or event. You’re not picking from a generic menu—we’re building something that fits your specific situation and guest preferences.
We bring everything directly to you: grills, gas, utensils, sauces, and the food. Whether it’s your backyard, a beach, public venue, or any other area, our grillmasters set up your private BBQ and handle the cooking. Day of the event, you focus on your guests while we focus on making sure the food exceeds expectations.
Ready to get started?
Long Island Catering Options
From standard meals like breakfast and lunch to specialty menus like Italian catering and desserts, we offer menu items and catering options for any occasion. Our BBQ catering features fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy grilled barbecue chicken, burgers, and hot dogs—we’re masters of the grill.
What makes Atlantic Beach events special is the coastal lifestyle and the expectation for quality that comes with it. Consumers are increasingly concerned about environmental impact, leading to demand for sustainable catering with minimized plastic use and locally sourced ingredients. We source locally when possible, not because it’s trendy, but because it tastes better and supports our community.
We can add professional wait staff to ensure everyone’s needs are met so you and your guests have the best time at your event. Some events need that extra level of service, and we know which ones those are.
How far in advance should I book catering for my Atlantic Beach event?
For most events, two weeks notice gives us enough time to plan properly and source the freshest ingredients. However, we’ve handled last-minute requests when needed, especially for smaller corporate meetings or family gatherings.
86% of catering companies report being understaffed, with high turnover rates making it difficult to maintain consistency. We maintain our own trained staff specifically to avoid the quality issues that come with last-minute staffing. Peak seasons like summer BBQ season and holiday parties book faster, so earlier is always better.
The key is calling us as soon as you know the date. Even if menu details aren’t finalized, securing your date ensures we can dedicate our team to making your event successful.
What's included in your BBQ catering package for Atlantic Beach events?
We cook hot dogs, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, BBQ ribs, grilled chicken, and corn on the cob. We bring freshly prepared homemade salads including potato, macaroni, and coleslaw, plus all buns and fixings like ketchup, mustard, mayo, pickles, and olives.
We bring grills, gas, utensils, sauces, and of course, the food directly to you. This isn’t drop-off catering where you’re left to figure out serving and cleanup. Our grillmasters handle the actual cooking on-site, so the food is served hot and fresh.
Setup and cleanup are included. You shouldn’t have to spend your event managing logistics or cleaning up afterward. We arrive early, set up everything, cook throughout your event, and leave your space cleaner than we found it.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions for Atlantic Beach catering events?
Offering dishes that cater to different religious, cultural, or dietary restrictions like halal, kosher, or vegetarian meals makes catering services more accessible to a broader audience. We regularly handle gluten-free, dairy-free, vegetarian, and other dietary needs.
The key is discussing these requirements during planning, not the day of your event. We can modify most of our menu items or create separate preparations to ensure everyone at your event has something delicious to eat. This includes separate cooking surfaces for allergies and clearly labeled serving areas.
Clients increasingly expect personalized and customizable menus tailored to specific tastes and dietary needs, whether gluten-free, dairy-free, or allergen-friendly meals. We’ve found that addressing dietary restrictions properly actually makes events more inclusive and enjoyable for everyone.
What areas around Atlantic Beach do you serve for catering?
We provide catering services throughout Long Island, including Atlantic Beach, East Atlantic Beach, Long Beach, and the broader Nassau County area. Our service area covers most of Nassau and Suffolk Counties, so if you’re planning an event anywhere on Long Island, we can likely accommodate you.
Distance affects logistics more than cost. Beach locations require different setup considerations than backyard events or indoor venues. We factor in travel time, equipment transport, and local regulations when planning your event.
Professional catering companies serve throughout Nassau, Suffolk, Brooklyn, Queens, and NYC, providing assistance with planning events at your home, office, or location of choice. We’ve catered events from intimate home gatherings to large corporate functions across Long Island.
How does pricing work for Brendel's Bagels catering in Atlantic Beach?
Our premium BBQ catering package is an incredible deal that really can’t be beaten. Pricing depends on menu selection, guest count, service level, and event complexity. A basic breakfast bagel spread costs less than full-service BBQ with wait staff.
We offer delectable food and service with a smile at the fairest, most affordable prices, which is why our catering services are regarded as the best in the area. We provide detailed quotes upfront, so there are no surprises on your bill.
The value comes from what’s included. When we quote BBQ catering, that includes the grilling equipment, setup, cooking, serving, and cleanup. Many caterers charge separately for service elements that we include in our base pricing. Call us for a specific quote based on your event details.
What makes Brendel's Bagels different from other Atlantic Beach caterers?
Our approach to preparing and serving really makes us a cut above the rest. We use the freshest ingredients, many locally sourced, and freshly prepare all dishes. When we say fresh, we mean fresh.
Most catering companies either specialize in one type of food or offer generic options across categories. We started as a bagel shop known for traditional kettle-cooking methods, then expanded into full catering while maintaining that same commitment to quality and craftsmanship.
Whether you’re hosting a baby shower, bridal shower, birthday party, corporate event, backyard BBQ, christening, or Super Bowl party, when you choose Brendel’s, you’ll leave a lasting impression on your guests and be able to sit back, relax, and enjoy your event. That’s the real difference—we handle the details so you can focus on what matters.
Local Resources