Catering in Bay Shore, NY
Your Event Handled From Start to Finish
Hear from Our Customers
Professional Bay Shore Catering Services
You planned this event to bring people together, not to spend it running around with platters and worrying about empty chafing dishes. When you choose our Bay Shore catering services, you get to actually attend your own event.
We show up with everything – the grills, the utensils, the professional staff, and most importantly, food that people will remember. Our catering company handles the setup, manages the service, and takes care of cleanup so you can focus on what matters: your guests, your celebration, your success.
No more wondering if there’s enough food, if it’s staying warm, or if someone’s handling the logistics. We’ve got it covered, and you’ll know it from the moment we arrive at your Bay Shore venue.
Bay Shore Catering Company
Brendels Bagels started as Bay Shore’s go-to spot for fresh, kettle-cooked bagels, but we’ve grown into something bigger. We’re now one of Suffolk County’s leading catering companies, serving events across Long Island with the same commitment to quality that made our bagels famous in the Bay Shore community.
Our approach to catering services is different. We don’t just drop off food and leave. We bring our grills directly to your Bay Shore location, set up your event like it’s our own, and staff it with professionals who care about your success. Whether it’s a corporate lunch downtown or a backyard BBQ near the marina, we treat every event with the attention it deserves.
Local ingredients, traditional methods, and a team that understands Bay Shore events – that’s what sets our catering company apart in a crowded Suffolk County market.
How Bay Shore Event Catering Works
First, we talk. Call our dedicated catering line at 1-866-CATERING and tell us about your Bay Shore event. We’ll discuss your vision, guest count, dietary needs, and budget to create a catering menu that fits perfectly with your celebration and venue requirements.
Next, we plan everything. From the timeline to the setup requirements, our catering services team handles the logistics so you don’t have to. We’ll coordinate delivery times, staff assignments, and equipment needs based on your Bay Shore venue and event type. We know the local venues, from waterfront locations to corporate facilities, and plan accordingly.
Finally, we execute. On event day, our catering company arrives early to set up, brings all necessary equipment including grills and serving stations, and manages the entire food service. When your event ends, we clean up and pack out, leaving your Bay Shore location exactly as we found it.
You get to enjoy your event while we handle what we do best – delivering exceptional catering services that make you look good to your guests.
Ready to get started?
Bay Shore Catering Food Options
Our Bay Shore catering menu goes far beyond our famous bagels. We specialize in premium BBQ catering with on-site grilling, bringing fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy chicken, and all the fixings directly to your Bay Shore event. Our Italian catering features authentic dishes made with locally-sourced ingredients, from hearty pasta dishes to fresh antipasto spreads that reflect the area’s diverse culinary preferences.
For corporate clients in Bay Shore and throughout Suffolk County, we offer breakfast catering with our signature kettle-cooked bagels, continental breakfast spreads, and hot breakfast buffets. Our lunch catering includes sandwich platters, fresh salads, and customizable options that work for office meetings, client presentations, or company events in Bay Shore’s business district.
Bay Shore’s event scene is diverse, from waterfront weddings near the marina to corporate gatherings in local venues, and we’ve adapted our catering services to match. We provide professional wait staff, complete table service, and can accommodate events from intimate gatherings of 20 to large celebrations of 250+ guests. Every catering menu is customizable, every service is professional, and every Bay Shore event gets our full attention to detail and quality standards.
How far in advance should I book catering services in Bay Shore?
For most Bay Shore events, we recommend booking our catering services 2-3 weeks in advance, especially during peak seasons like summer and fall when Bay Shore hosts many outdoor events and waterfront weddings. However, we can often accommodate shorter notice for corporate catering or smaller gatherings.
Peak times like graduation season, holidays, and summer wedding season fill up quickly in the Bay Shore area, so earlier booking ensures you get your preferred date and menu options. For large events over 100 guests or events requiring extensive setup like our BBQ catering with on-site grilling, 3-4 weeks notice gives us time to properly plan and staff your Bay Shore event.
If you have a last-minute event, still call us. We maintain flexibility in our catering services schedule and can often work with shorter timelines, especially for our breakfast and lunch catering that don’t require as much on-site preparation at your Bay Shore venue.
What's included with your BBQ catering service in Bay Shore?
Our Bay Shore BBQ catering is comprehensive – we bring everything needed for a complete outdoor cooking experience to your location. This includes our professional-grade grills, all gas and fuel, cooking utensils, serving equipment, and experienced grill masters who handle all the cooking on-site at your Bay Shore event.
Food-wise, you get traditional BBQ favorites: fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy grilled chicken, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, hot dogs, and corn on the cob. We include freshly prepared homemade sides like potato salad, macaroni salad, and coleslaw, plus all the buns, condiments, pickles, and fixings that make a great Bay Shore BBQ.
What makes this catering service special is that we handle everything from setup to cleanup. Our team arrives early to set up the grilling station, manages all the cooking during your Bay Shore event so you can enjoy time with guests, and handles complete cleanup afterward. We can also provide professional wait staff to ensure all your guests are properly attended to throughout the event.
Do you accommodate dietary restrictions for Bay Shore catering?
Absolutely. We work with Bay Shore clients to create customized catering menus that accommodate various dietary needs including vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and other specific requirements. Our approach is to discuss your needs upfront and build a catering menu that ensures all your guests have delicious options.
For corporate catering in Bay Shore, we often create diverse menus that include lighter options, plant-based choices, and traditional favorites to satisfy different preferences. Our Italian catering can be adapted for various dietary restrictions, and we can modify our breakfast catering offerings to include gluten-free bagel options and dairy-free alternatives.
The key is communication during the planning process. When you call our catering line, let us know about any dietary restrictions or special requests for your Bay Shore event. We’ll work with you to create solutions that don’t compromise on taste or presentation. Our locally-sourced ingredients and made-to-order approach gives us flexibility that many larger catering companies can’t match.
What areas do you serve for catering beyond Bay Shore?
We provide catering services throughout Suffolk County and across Long Island, with Bay Shore as one of our key service areas. Our coverage includes Bay Shore, Babylon, Islip, Huntington, Smithtown, Commack, and many other Long Island communities. We’ve catered events from the South Shore beaches to North Shore venues.
Our multiple Long Island locations allow us to efficiently serve a wide geographic area while maintaining our commitment to fresh, locally-sourced ingredients for every catering order. Whether you’re planning a corporate event in Melville, a wedding in the Hamptons, or a family celebration in Nassau County, we can bring our full-service catering to your location.
Distance isn’t usually an issue for larger catering events, and we factor travel into our planning and pricing upfront so there are no surprises. When you contact us about catering services, we’ll confirm that your location is within our service area and discuss any logistical considerations for your specific venue.
How does pricing work for your Bay Shore catering services?
Our Bay Shore catering pricing is straightforward and based on several factors: guest count, menu selection, service level, and any additional staff or equipment needed. We provide detailed quotes that break down all catering costs so you know exactly what you’re paying for with no hidden fees.
Basic catering packages start with food costs per person, but pricing varies significantly between a simple breakfast delivery and our full-service BBQ catering with on-site grilling and staff. Corporate catering for regular lunch deliveries often qualifies for volume pricing, while special event catering includes service charges for setup, staffing, and cleanup.
We always provide written estimates after discussing your specific Bay Shore catering needs. This includes food costs, any rental equipment, staffing charges, and delivery fees if applicable. For Bay Shore events, we’re often able to offer competitive catering pricing because of our local presence and established vendor relationships. The best approach is to call us with your event details for an accurate, customized quote.
Can you handle both the catering and event coordination for my Bay Shore celebration?
While we focus primarily on catering excellence, we do provide comprehensive event support that goes beyond just food service for Bay Shore events. Our catering team coordinates timing, manages setup and breakdown, and works with your other vendors to ensure smooth event flow. We’ve handled hundreds of events and understand how catering integrates with the broader event timeline.
For corporate events in Bay Shore, we often coordinate with facilities managers and IT teams to ensure our catering service doesn’t disrupt business operations. For social events, we work with venues, decorators, and entertainment to make sure food service enhances rather than competes with other event elements.
However, for full event planning services like venue selection, decor, and entertainment booking, we recommend working with a dedicated event planner while we handle the catering component. We’re happy to collaborate with event planners you’re already working with, or we can recommend trusted partners in the Bay Shore area who share our commitment to quality and professionalism in catering services.
Local Resources