Catering in East Garden City, NY
Food That Actually Impresses Your Guests
Hear from Our Customers
Professional Catering Services East Garden City
You’re not just getting food delivered in aluminum trays. You’re getting a catering partner who shows up with everything—the grill, the utensils, the setup, the cleanup, and the kind of fresh food that makes people ask where you ordered from.
When you work with a catering company that actually understands events, you spend less time worrying about logistics and more time enjoying your own gathering. Your guests taste the difference in our kettle-cooked bagels and locally sourced ingredients.
The result? An event that feels effortless for you and memorable for everyone else. No stress, no corners cut, no wondering if the food will show up on time or taste good.
Long Island Catering Company
We operate multiple locations across Long Island, serving East Garden City and surrounding Nassau County communities with the same commitment to quality that built our reputation. We’re not just another catering company—we’re a full-service eatery that happens to excel at events.
Our bagels are made using traditional kettle-cooking methods that create that perfect chewy interior and crispy exterior you can’t get from mass-produced alternatives. We source fresh, often local ingredients because you can taste the difference, and your guests deserve better than generic catering food.
What sets us apart in the Long Island catering market is our comprehensive approach. We don’t just drop off food—we bring the equipment, handle the setup, manage the service, and take care of cleanup so you can focus on what matters most.
East Garden City Catering Process
First, we discuss your event needs, guest count, and menu preferences. Whether you want traditional bagel spreads, Italian catering, or our premium BBQ service where we bring the grill directly to your location, we customize the menu to match your event.
Next, we handle all the logistics. Our professional staff arrives with everything needed—serving equipment, utensils, setup materials, and of course, freshly prepared food. For BBQ catering, we bring our own grilling equipment and manage the entire cooking process on-site.
During your event, our attentive team manages food service so you can focus on your guests. When the event concludes, we handle all cleanup and equipment removal, leaving your space exactly as we found it. You get to enjoy your own event instead of spending it in the kitchen or worrying about logistics.
Ready to get started?
Catering Menu Options East Garden City
Our catering services extend far beyond breakfast bagels, though our kettle-cooked bagels with premium spreads remain a crowd favorite. We offer comprehensive Italian catering featuring authentic dishes that satisfy diverse tastes, plus an extensive selection of gourmet sandwiches and fresh salads prepared with quality ingredients.
For outdoor events and corporate gatherings, our premium BBQ catering service brings restaurant-quality grilling directly to your East Garden City location. We arrive with professional grills, all necessary equipment, and experienced staff who manage the entire cooking and service process.
Our dessert trays and baked goods round out any event menu, while our flexible service options accommodate everything from intimate office meetings to large community gatherings. Each catering package includes professional staff, complete setup and breakdown, serving equipment, and the peace of mind that comes from working with an established Long Island catering company that understands local preferences and expectations.
How far in advance should I book catering services in East Garden City?
For most events, booking 3-7 days in advance gives us enough time to prepare fresh food and coordinate logistics properly. However, we can often accommodate shorter notice for smaller orders, especially during weekdays.
Larger events or those requiring our premium BBQ service with on-site grilling typically need more lead time to ensure we have the right equipment and staffing available. Holiday periods and peak event seasons may require booking further ahead.
If you’re planning something last-minute, call us anyway. We’ll do our best to accommodate your timeline, and our multiple Long Island locations often allow us more flexibility than single-location caterers.
What's included in your full-service catering beyond just the food?
Full-service means we handle everything from setup to cleanup. We arrive with all serving equipment, utensils, plates, napkins, and any specialized equipment needed for your menu selections. For BBQ catering, we bring our own professional grills and cooking equipment.
Our staff manages the entire food service process, so you’re not stuck behind a serving table during your own event. We set up buffet stations or individual service as needed, maintain food temperatures throughout your event, and handle all guest interactions around food service.
After your event, we pack up all equipment, dispose of food service waste, and leave your space clean. You shouldn’t have to wash dishes or figure out what to do with leftover aluminum trays—that’s all part of what you’re paying for.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions and special menu requests for catering?
Yes, we work with dietary restrictions and special requests regularly. Our extensive menu already includes vegetarian options, and we can accommodate gluten-free needs, dairy-free requests, and other common dietary concerns with advance notice.
Since we prepare food fresh rather than relying entirely on pre-made items, we have more flexibility than many catering companies. Our Italian catering options include lighter fare and vegetable-focused dishes, while our sandwich and salad selections can be customized for various dietary preferences.
The key is discussing these needs when you book, not the day of your event. This gives our kitchen team time to source appropriate ingredients and prepare items safely to avoid cross-contamination concerns.
What makes your BBQ catering different from other catering companies in the area?
We bring the actual grilling experience to your location rather than pre-cooking everything and reheating it. Our team arrives with professional-grade grills and handles all the cooking on-site, so your guests get genuinely fresh-grilled food with the authentic BBQ experience.
This approach means better-tasting food and the visual appeal of live grilling, which adds atmosphere to outdoor events and corporate gatherings. We handle all aspects including bringing our own equipment, managing cooking times, and maintaining proper food safety throughout the process.
Most catering companies either don’t offer BBQ at all or deliver pre-cooked items that have been sitting in warming trays. Our on-site approach delivers restaurant-quality results with the convenience of full-service catering, including all cleanup afterward.
How do you ensure food stays fresh for longer events or outdoor gatherings?
We use professional food warming and cooling equipment to maintain proper temperatures throughout your event, regardless of duration or outdoor conditions. Our staff monitors food temperatures and refreshes items as needed to ensure both safety and quality.
For outdoor events, we bring additional equipment to protect food from weather and maintain serving temperatures. Our experience with Long Island’s varied weather conditions means we come prepared for temperature fluctuations and unexpected conditions.
We also time our food preparation and delivery to ensure maximum freshness upon arrival. Items that are best served immediately get priority timing, while dishes that hold well are prepared to peak quality during your event’s key serving periods.
What's your pricing structure and minimum order requirements for East Garden City catering?
Our catering pricing depends on menu selections, guest count, and service level required. Basic bagel spreads and continental breakfast options start at different price points than our premium BBQ catering with on-site grilling and full service.
We typically require minimum orders that make logistical sense—usually around 10-12 people for delivery orders and slightly higher minimums for full-service events that require our staff and equipment. These minimums help us maintain quality while keeping pricing reasonable.
The best approach is calling for a specific quote based on your exact needs. We’ll discuss your event requirements, provide transparent pricing for different service levels, and help you find the right balance of menu options and service that fits your budget while meeting your event goals.
Local Resources