Catering in Eastport, NY
Your Event, Perfectly Catered
Hear from Our Customers
Professional Catering Services Eastport
You know the drill. Most catering companies drop off lukewarm food and disappear. You’re left coordinating everything else, stressed about whether guests will actually enjoy what they’re eating, and missing your own event because you’re playing host and caterer.
Here’s what happens when you choose catering that’s designed around your needs, not ours. Your guests walk into an event where everything just works. The food smells incredible because it’s being prepared fresh on-site. You’re mingling instead of managing because our team handles setup, cooking, and cleanup. People are actually talking about how good the food is instead of politely pushing it around their plates.
The difference is simple: we show up as your full-service catering team, not just a food delivery service. You get to be the host you wanted to be, and your guests get an experience worth remembering.
Eastport NY Catering Company
We’ve been serving Suffolk County for years, and we’ve learned something important: great catering isn’t just about great food. It’s about understanding what you actually need when you’re planning an event in Eastport.
We started as Long Island’s go-to spot for authentic New York-style bagels, made the traditional way with kettle-cooking methods. But our clients kept asking us to cater their events because they trusted our commitment to quality and freshness. Now we operate four locations across Long Island and handle everything from intimate corporate meetings to large celebrations.
What makes us different is simple: we’re obsessed with getting the details right. Fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Recipes crafted specifically for flavor, not just convenience. And service that actually serves you, not the other way around.
How Catering Works Eastport
First, we talk through what you’re planning. Not just headcount and budget, but what kind of experience you want your guests to have. Are you looking for our signature BBQ service where we bring the grills and handle everything on-site? Italian catering with traditional fare? Breakfast catering for a corporate event? We customize everything to fit your specific needs.
Next, we handle the logistics you don’t want to think about. Menu planning, ingredient sourcing, equipment, setup timing. If you’re choosing our BBQ catering, that means we bring the grills, gas, utensils, and everything else needed to create a complete outdoor cooking experience at your location.
On event day, our team arrives early and takes care of everything. We set up, prepare food fresh throughout your event, and handle complete cleanup afterward. You focus on your guests. We focus on making sure the food and service exceed expectations.
Ready to get started?
Catering Menu Options Eastport
Our catering menu reflects what actually works for events in Eastport and throughout Suffolk County. We offer one of the largest and most diverse catering menus in the area because different events need different approaches.
Our BBQ catering is especially popular for Long Island events. We bring everything needed for a complete outdoor cooking experience: professional grills, gas, utensils, and our grillmasters who handle all the cooking. You get fall-off-the-bone ribs, perfectly grilled chicken, burgers, and hot dogs prepared fresh throughout your event. No reheated food, no guesswork about equipment.
For Italian catering, we focus on traditional fare done right: stuffed shells, meat lasagna, baked ziti, penne alla vodka, chicken marsala, and chicken Francese. We also create fresh heroes, paninis, and wraps using Boar’s Head cold cuts and our homemade dipping sauces. Everything is prepared with the same attention to quality that made our bagel shops a Long Island favorite.
Breakfast and lunch catering options include our signature kettle-cooked bagels with homemade cream cheeses, plus sandwiches, salads, and baked goods that work for corporate meetings, family gatherings, or any event where you need food that’s both convenient and impressive.
How far in advance should I book catering services in Eastport?
For most events, booking 1-2 weeks in advance gives us enough time to plan your menu and coordinate logistics properly. However, we can often accommodate shorter notice for smaller events, especially breakfast or lunch catering.
For larger events or our full BBQ catering service (where we bring grills and handle on-site cooking), booking 2-3 weeks ahead is better. This ensures we can reserve the right equipment and staff for your specific date and location in Eastport.
Holiday periods and summer months tend to book faster, so earlier is always better if you have flexibility. When you call 1-866-CATERING, we’ll let you know exactly what’s possible for your timeline and help you secure the date.
What's included in your BBQ catering service for Eastport events?
Our BBQ catering is a complete service, not just food delivery. We bring professional grills, gas, all cooking utensils, serving equipment, and our experienced grillmasters who handle the entire cooking process at your location.
Food-wise, you get fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy grilled barbecue chicken, burgers, hot dogs, and sides prepared fresh throughout your event. We use locally sourced ingredients when possible and prepare everything on-site so your guests get the authentic BBQ experience.
We handle complete setup before your event starts and full cleanup afterward. You don’t need to provide anything except the location and guests. Whether it’s your backyard in Eastport, a beach venue, or a public space, we bring everything needed to create a professional BBQ experience that lets you actually enjoy your own event.
Do you accommodate dietary restrictions and special requests for catering?
Yes, we work with dietary restrictions and special menu requests regularly. Our extensive menu already includes vegetarian options, and we can modify many dishes to accommodate specific needs like gluten-free requirements or food allergies.
The key is discussing these needs when you book your catering. This gives us time to plan properly and ensure we have the right ingredients and preparation methods. We’ve handled everything from corporate events with multiple dietary restrictions to family celebrations with specific cultural food preferences.
For our Italian catering, we can adjust pasta dishes, modify sauces, or create custom sandwich combinations. Our breakfast catering includes options beyond bagels, and even our BBQ service can accommodate different dietary needs with alternative proteins and sides. Just let us know what you need when you call 1-866-CATERING.
What areas around Eastport do you provide catering services to?
We provide catering services throughout Suffolk County, including all areas around Eastport. Our service area covers the entire Long Island region, from the East End communities to central Suffolk County locations.
With four locations across Long Island, we’re positioned to serve events efficiently throughout the region. Whether your event is in Eastport proper, nearby communities like Speonk or Remsenburg, or anywhere else in Suffolk County, we can accommodate your catering needs.
Distance doesn’t typically affect our service quality because we plan logistics carefully for each location. For our BBQ catering service, we factor in travel time for equipment transport and setup. For other catering options, we coordinate delivery timing to ensure food arrives at optimal temperature and freshness regardless of your specific location within our service area.
How do you ensure food stays fresh for outdoor events and longer celebrations?
Food freshness is handled differently depending on your catering choice, but it’s always a priority. For our BBQ catering, freshness isn’t an issue because we’re cooking everything on-site throughout your event. Food goes from grill to plate, so guests get the freshest possible experience.
For other catering options, we use professional food service techniques including proper temperature control, insulated transport containers, and strategic delivery timing. We also plan menu items specifically for the type of event and duration to ensure everything tastes as good at the end as it did when we prepared it.
Our years of experience catering events throughout Suffolk County means we know how to handle Long Island’s weather conditions and typical event logistics. We plan for everything from indoor corporate meetings to outdoor celebrations, adjusting our preparation and service methods to maintain food quality and safety throughout your entire event.
What makes your catering different from other companies serving Eastport?
The biggest difference is that we’re actually a full-service catering company, not just a food delivery service. When you book our BBQ catering, we bring grills, equipment, and staff who handle cooking and cleanup. You get a complete experience, not just dropped-off food.
Our food quality comes from the same commitment that made our bagel shops popular across Long Island: kettle-cooked bagels, locally sourced ingredients when possible, and recipes crafted for flavor rather than just convenience. We’re not trying to be the cheapest option – we’re focused on being the option that actually works for your event.
We also offer one of the most diverse catering menus in Suffolk County. From traditional New York-style breakfast catering to authentic Italian fare to premium BBQ experiences, we can handle events that other catering companies can’t accommodate. Most importantly, our team understands Long Island events and what it takes to make them successful, which shows in both our food and our service approach.
Local Resources