Catering in Old Bethpage, NY
Your Event, Perfectly Catered
Hear from Our Customers
Old Bethpage Catering Services
You planned this event to bring people together, not to spend it stressed in the kitchen or hovering over a grill. When you choose professional catering in Old Bethpage, you get to do what you actually wanted – enjoy the company, celebrate the moment, and watch your guests light up over incredible food.
No need to stand behind a hot barbecue or miss out on your event; when you hire us, we’ll take care of all the setup, cooking, and cleanup so you can mix and mingle with your guests. That’s the difference between throwing food at an event and creating an experience people talk about long after they leave.
Your guests notice fresh ingredients. They taste the difference between made-to-order dishes and reheated catering trays. We use the freshest ingredients (many of which are locally sourced) and all of our menu items are made-to-order; you won’t find any pre-made dishes here!
Catering Company Old Bethpage
At Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we offer more than just the best bagels in Nassau County! We also provide full-service catering services. What started as our commitment to traditional kettle-cooked bagels has grown into comprehensive catering that serves Old Bethpage and Nassau County with the same attention to quality.
Our celebrated kettle-cooked bagels delight the senses: crispy on the outside, yet warm and fluffy inside. Each bagel we make shows our commitment to quality and taste, making us a favorite stop for bagel lovers across Long Island. That same dedication shows up in every catering menu we create.
Whether you’re in Old Bethpage planning a corporate meeting or a family celebration, you’re working with a catering company that understands Nassau County events and what makes them successful.
How Our Catering Works
First, we talk about your event. Not just headcount and budget – what are you trying to create? A relaxed backyard BBQ? An impressive corporate lunch? A memorable family celebration? Choose from any of the hand-selected items on our catering menu or create your own customized menu. We’ll work with you to create a creative lunch catering or dinner catering experience that will be sure to leave your guests happy.
Next, we handle the details. Grills, gas, utensils, sauces, and of course, the food; we bring the BBQ directly to you! Whether it’s your backyard, a beach, a public venue, or any other area, our grillmasters will set up your very own private BBQ and will man the grill for you. For other catering styles, the same principle applies – we bring everything needed to execute your menu perfectly.
Finally, you enjoy your event while we work. Would you like to add some wait staff to make sure all of your guests are attended to? We can cover that for you, too! Our professional wait staff will ensure that everyone’s needs are met so that you and your guests can have the absolute best time at your outdoor event!
Ready to get started?
Old Bethpage Event Catering
Whether you’re hosting a bridal shower, a birthday party, a holiday dinner, a Super Bowl party, or any other event, you can count on us to make everyone smile with our incredible catering. Old Bethpage hosts everything from intimate family gatherings to large corporate events, and our catering adapts to fit.
Celebrate an early or mid-morning affair with our Petite Continental Breakfast, Rise & Shine Continental Breakfast, Brendel’s Spa-Lite Breakfast, Sunrise Hot Breakfast Buffet, Smoked Fish Presentation, Breakfast Heroes and Wraps, Omelets, and of course, an assortment of the freshest bagels in Nassau County, NY complete with an array of our homemade cream cheese spreads. For Nassau County events that need something more substantial, our Italian catering brings authentic flavors that satisfy every palate.
BBQ catering remains one of our specialties in the Old Bethpage area. Hot dogs, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, BBQ ribs, grilled chicken, corn on the cob; we cook it all! We’ll bring freshly prepared, homemade salads, too, including potato, macaroni, and coleslaw. Of course, all of the buns and fixings, such as ketchup, mustard, mayo, and even pickles and olives are included with our premium BBQ catering package!
How far in advance should I book catering in Old Bethpage?
For most events in Old Bethpage and Nassau County, we recommend booking at least two weeks in advance, especially during peak seasons like spring and summer when outdoor events are popular. However, we understand that some events come together quickly, and we’ll do our best to accommodate shorter notice when possible.
The earlier you book, the more flexibility you’ll have with menu customization and service options. Popular dates like weekends, holidays, and graduation season fill up faster, so if you have a specific date in mind, reaching out early ensures you get exactly what you want for your event.
What's included with your BBQ catering service in Old Bethpage?
Our BBQ catering service brings everything directly to your Old Bethpage location – grills, gas, utensils, and professional grillmasters who handle all the cooking. We don’t just drop off food; we create a complete BBQ experience at your venue.
The menu includes traditional BBQ favorites like ribs, grilled chicken, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, and hot dogs, plus sides like corn on the cob and freshly prepared salads including potato, macaroni, and coleslaw. All condiments, buns, and fixings are included. We handle setup, cooking, and cleanup, so you can focus on enjoying your event with your guests.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions for Old Bethpage events?
Absolutely. We work with you to create customized menus that accommodate various dietary needs and preferences. Whether you need vegetarian options, gluten-free choices, or specific allergy considerations, we’ll discuss these requirements during our menu planning conversation.
Our made-to-order approach means we’re not limited to pre-set menu items. We can modify preparations, substitute ingredients, and create alternative options that ensure all your guests have delicious food they can enjoy. Just let us know about any dietary considerations when we discuss your catering needs.
Do you provide catering staff for events in Old Bethpage?
Yes, we offer professional wait staff as part of our full-service catering options. Our staff can handle serving, beverage service, and general event assistance, allowing you to be a guest at your own event rather than managing food service.
For BBQ catering, our grillmasters are included and handle all the cooking and grill management. Additional wait staff can be added based on your event size and service level preferences. We’ll discuss staffing options during your catering consultation to determine what level of service works best for your Old Bethpage event.
What areas around Old Bethpage do you serve for catering?
We provide catering services throughout Nassau County and across Long Island, with Old Bethpage being well within our primary service area. Whether your event is at your home, a local venue, or an outdoor location in the Old Bethpage area, we bring our full-service catering directly to you.
Our service area includes surrounding communities throughout Nassau County, and we regularly cater events at various venues, parks, and private locations. Distance isn’t typically an issue for events in the Old Bethpage area – we’ll discuss your specific location during the planning process to confirm logistics and any delivery considerations.
How do you ensure food quality and freshness for catered events?
Food quality starts with our commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients whenever possible, and extends through our made-to-order preparation approach. We don’t use pre-made dishes or food that’s been sitting – everything is prepared specifically for your event.
For BBQ catering, we bring the grills and cook everything fresh on-site, so your guests get food at peak quality and temperature. For other catering styles, we time our preparation and delivery to ensure optimal freshness. Our traditional kettle-cooking methods for bagels and attention to ingredient quality in all our menu items reflects the same standards we apply to our catering services.
Local Resources