Catering in Plainedge, NY
Food That Actually Impresses Your Guests
Hear from Our Customers
Plainedge Event Catering Services
You’re not just getting food delivered in aluminum trays. You’re getting a team that shows up early, sets everything up properly, and handles the cooking while you enjoy your guests.
No more worrying about whether the caterer will actually show up or if the food will still be hot. No more scrambling to find serving utensils or dealing with cleanup afterward.
Your guests taste the difference when food is made fresh, not reheated. They notice when someone actually cares about presentation and service quality.
Trusted Long Island Catering Company
Brendels Bagels has been the go-to catering choice across Long Island for years, and there’s a reason why. We’re not just another bagel shop trying to do catering on the side.
We’re a full-service catering company with four Long Island locations and a reputation built on showing up when we say we will with food that actually tastes good. Our kettle-cooked bagels and made-to-order dishes have made us a favorite among families and businesses throughout Suffolk County.
When Plainedge residents need catering they can count on, they call us because we understand what matters: fresh food, reliable service, and taking care of the details so their events succeed.
How Our Catering Process Works
First, we talk through your event needs, guest count, and menu preferences. No generic packages forced on you – we customize based on what you actually want and need.
Next, we prepare everything fresh using quality ingredients, many sourced locally. For BBQ events, we bring our own grills and equipment directly to your location. For other catering, we prep everything to order right before your event.
On event day, our team arrives early to set up properly. We handle the cooking, serving, and all the details while you focus on your guests. When it’s over, we clean everything up and pack out our equipment. You’re left with happy guests and no mess to deal with.
Ready to get started?
Complete Catering Services Plainedge
Our catering covers breakfast meetings, lunch events, dinner parties, and everything in between. BBQ catering includes on-site grilling with fall-off-the-bone ribs, juicy chicken, burgers, and all the sides. Italian catering features fresh pasta dishes, specialty heroes, and authentic flavors.
For corporate events in the Plainedge business community, we provide professional presentation and reliable timing. Family celebrations get the same attention to detail, whether it’s a backyard party or formal gathering.
We also handle the extras that other caterers forget about – tables, chairs, tents for outdoor events, and professional wait staff when needed. Beverage service includes soft drinks, bottled water, juices, coffee, and specialty teas. Everything comes with proper serving equipment, plates, napkins, and utensils.
How far in advance should I book catering services in Plainedge?
For most events, booking 1-2 weeks ahead gives us enough time to plan your menu and secure the date. However, we can often accommodate shorter notice for smaller events or standard menu items.
Larger events with 50+ guests or custom menu requests work best with 2-3 weeks notice. Holiday periods and popular event seasons (like graduation and wedding season) fill up faster, so earlier booking helps ensure availability.
If you have a last-minute event, still give us a call. We’ll do everything possible to make it work, and we’ve pulled together quality catering with just a few days notice when the situation called for it.
What's included with your BBQ catering service in Plainedge?
Our BBQ catering is full-service, meaning we bring everything needed for fresh grilling at your location. This includes the grills, gas, utensils, serving equipment, and all the food ingredients.
Our grill masters handle all the cooking on-site, so you get fresh-grilled ribs, chicken, burgers, and hot dogs instead of pre-cooked food that’s been sitting around. We also provide traditional BBQ sides and sauces.
Setup and cleanup are included in the service. We arrive early to get everything ready, manage the grilling throughout your event, and pack everything out when finished. You don’t touch a spatula or deal with any cleanup – that’s what makes this service valuable for busy hosts.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions and special menu requests?
Yes, we customize menus regularly for dietary needs and preferences. Whether it’s vegetarian options, gluten-free items, or specific cultural food requests, we work with you to create something that works.
Our kitchen team has experience preparing alternatives that don’t compromise on taste. For example, we can create vegetarian heroes with grilled vegetables and specialty cheeses, or modify our Italian dishes to accommodate different dietary needs.
The key is discussing these requirements during the planning phase. When we know about restrictions upfront, we can suggest alternatives and make sure everyone at your event has good food options they can actually eat and enjoy.
How do you ensure food quality and freshness for large catering orders?
We prepare everything made-to-order, which means we don’t start cooking until right before your event or we prepare items fresh on-site. This approach keeps food at peak quality instead of sitting around for hours.
Our ingredients are sourced fresh, with many items coming from local suppliers when possible. For items like our signature bagels, we use the same kettle-cooking method for catering orders that we use in our retail locations.
Temperature control is handled properly during transport and service. Hot foods stay hot, cold items stay properly chilled, and we have the equipment needed to maintain food safety standards throughout your event.
What types of events do you typically cater in the Plainedge area?
We handle everything from corporate breakfast meetings and business lunches to family celebrations like birthday parties, baby showers, and graduation parties. Many local businesses use us for employee appreciation events and client meetings.
Backyard BBQs are popular, especially during summer months when families want professional grilling without the work. We also cater formal events like anniversary parties and holiday gatherings where presentation and service quality matter.
Religious celebrations, sports viewing parties, and community events round out our typical bookings. The common thread is hosts who want good food and reliable service without having to manage all the details themselves.
Do you provide catering equipment and staff for events?
Yes, we provide all necessary serving equipment including chafing dishes, serving utensils, plates, napkins, and cups as part of our standard catering service. For outdoor events, we can also supply tables, chairs, and tents when needed.
Professional wait staff is available for larger events or formal occasions where you want full-service dining. Our staff handles food service, beverage refills, and table clearing so you can focus on hosting.
Setup and breakdown are included with all our catering packages. We arrive with enough time to get everything arranged properly before guests arrive, and we handle all cleanup and equipment removal at the end. This full-service approach is what sets us apart from delivery-only catering options.
Local Resources