Catering in Sagaponack, NY
Your Event, Perfectly Handled
Hear from Our Customers
Sagaponack Catering Company
You planned this event to bring people together, not to spend it running between the kitchen and your guests. When you choose Brendel’s Bagels for your Sagaponack catering, you get to be present for the moments that matter.
We handle everything from the first setup detail to the final cleanup. Your guests taste the difference in our kettle-cooked bagels and locally sourced ingredients. You experience the relief of professional service that actually works.
No rushing around. No last-minute panic. Just you, your guests, and the kind of event you actually wanted to host.
Long Island Catering Services
Brendel’s Bagels has been serving Long Island communities with more than just bagels. We’re a full-service eatery and premier catering company with multiple locations across the area.
Our commitment runs deeper than convenience. We use traditional kettle-cooking methods for our signature bagels – that chewy interior and crispy exterior you taste in every bite. Our ingredients are fresh, high-quality, and often locally sourced because we believe you should taste the difference.
Sagaponack residents know quality when they see it. That’s why we’ve built our reputation on delivering exactly what we promise, every time.
Catering Process Sagaponack
First, we discuss your event needs, guest count, and menu preferences. Whether you want our signature bagels for a morning gathering, Italian catering for a family celebration, or premium BBQ service for a backyard event, we customize everything to fit your vision.
Next, we handle all the logistics. For our premium BBQ catering, we bring our own grills, utensils, and professional staff directly to your location. For other events, we coordinate timing, setup, and service details so everything flows smoothly.
On event day, our team arrives early to set up completely. We serve your guests, manage the food service, and handle all cleanup afterward. You focus on hosting while we focus on the details that make your event successful.
Ready to get started?
Hamptons Event Catering
Our catering extends far beyond our famous bagels. We offer comprehensive Italian catering, elegant dessert trays, and premium BBQ service where we bring everything needed for outdoor cooking. Each service includes professional staff, proper equipment, and complete event management.
In Sagaponack, events often reflect the area’s appreciation for quality and authenticity. Our locally sourced ingredients connect with the Hamptons’ farm-to-table tradition, while our professional service meets the high standards expected in this community.
From intimate breakfast gatherings to large outdoor celebrations, we scale our service to match your event size and style. Our extensive menu accommodates different tastes and dietary needs, ensuring every guest finds something they genuinely enjoy.
How far in advance should I book catering for my Sagaponack event?
We recommend booking at least 72 hours in advance for all catering orders, though earlier booking is better for larger events or busy seasons. This timeline allows us to properly plan your menu, coordinate our staff, and ensure we have all necessary ingredients and equipment ready.
For premium BBQ catering or events during peak Hamptons season, we suggest booking even earlier. Popular dates fill quickly, and we want to guarantee availability for your specific event date and requirements.
Do you provide all equipment and staff for BBQ catering events?
Yes, our premium BBQ catering service includes everything needed for a complete outdoor cooking experience. We bring our own professional-grade grills, all cooking utensils, serving equipment, and experienced staff to handle the entire process.
Our team arrives early to set up the grilling station, manages all food preparation and cooking on-site, serves your guests, and handles complete cleanup afterward. You don’t need to provide anything except the location and your guest list.
What types of events do we cater in the Sagaponack area?
We cater a wide range of events throughout Sagaponack and the surrounding Hamptons area. This includes breakfast and brunch gatherings featuring our signature bagels, Italian-style family celebrations, backyard BBQ parties, corporate meetings, and special occasions like birthday parties or anniversary celebrations.
Our flexible service adapts to both intimate gatherings and larger events. Whether you’re hosting a casual pool party or an elegant dinner party, we customize our menu and service style to match your event’s atmosphere and your guests’ expectations.
Are your ingredients locally sourced and fresh?
We prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients and source locally whenever possible. Our commitment to quality starts with our traditional kettle-cooking method for bagels and extends to all our catering offerings.
Being located in the Hamptons area, we have access to excellent local farms and suppliers. We choose ingredients that not only taste better but also support the local community that we serve. This approach aligns with the farm-to-table values that many Sagaponack residents appreciate.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions and special requests?
Absolutely. Our extensive menu and flexible approach allow us to accommodate various dietary needs and preferences. Whether your guests require vegetarian options, have food allergies, or prefer specific preparation methods, we work with you to ensure everyone can enjoy the meal.
During our initial consultation, we discuss any dietary restrictions or special requests in detail. This allows us to plan appropriate menu modifications and ensure our staff understands any special preparation requirements for your event.
What's included in your full-service catering packages?
Our full-service catering includes menu planning, food preparation, professional staff, complete setup, guest service during the event, and thorough cleanup afterward. We handle every detail so you can focus entirely on enjoying your event and spending time with your guests.
For premium BBQ catering, this extends to bringing our own grilling equipment and managing all outdoor cooking on-site. For other catering styles, we coordinate timing, presentation, and service flow to ensure your event runs smoothly from start to finish.
Local Resources