Catering in Shelter Island, NY
Your Event Deserves Real Food
Hear from Our Customers
Professional Catering Services Shelter Island
Your guests notice when food is fresh. They taste the difference when ingredients are quality. They remember events where someone clearly put thought into what they’re serving.
We don’t prep your menu until right before your event or prepare it right on-site at your location. That means no soggy sandwiches sitting in warmers. No wilted salads that have been sitting since yesterday morning.
When you choose catering that’s actually made-to-order, your event feels different. Professional. Thoughtful. Like someone who understands that food is part of the experience, not just fuel to get through the day.
Shelter Island Catering Company
We’ve had the privilege of catering corporate events and business meetings for various Shelter Island business owners. We’re a favorite stop for bagel lovers across Long Island, but catering is where we really show what we can do.
Our celebrated kettle-cooked bagels are crispy on the outside, yet warm and fluffy inside. All of our menu items are lovingly crafted by our experienced chefs and made with only the highest quality, freshest ingredients.
Shelter Island knows quality when they taste it. That’s why local businesses and families keep coming back to us for their important events.
Catering Process Shelter Island NY
Give us a call at 1-866-CATERING and one of our friendly associates will start working with you right away to create a menu that’s customized to meet your every need. We talk through your event size, timing, dietary needs, and what kind of impression you want to make.
We plan everything from the menu to the setup. Need tables, chairs, or a tent for an outdoor event, or interested in hiring wait-staff? At Brendel’s, we have all of that covered, too!
On event day, we arrive early, set up everything, serve your guests, and handle cleanup. You focus on your event. We handle the food and service so it’s one less thing you need to worry about.
Ready to get started?
Catering Menu Options Shelter Island
We specialize in BBQ catering, Italian catering, breakfast catering, and more across Shelter Island. With our breakfast, lunch, and dinner catering packages, we guarantee a smooth and pleasant experience that matches your event’s unique taste and style.
Our traditional options include American and Italian heroes, made with fresh Boar’s Head Select cold cuts and prepared by-the-foot. We offer an assortment of freshly made custom paninis, signature sandwiches, and one-of-a-kind wraps.
For Shelter Island’s outdoor events and waterfront gatherings, our BBQ catering brings everything – the grill, utensils, and staff. Corporate meetings get our professional presentation with customizable platters. Want to create something unique? Let us know and we can certainly customize a menu just for you!
How far in advance should I book catering for my Shelter Island event?
We recommend booking at least 48-72 hours in advance for most events, though we can sometimes accommodate shorter notice depending on our schedule and your event size. For large corporate events, weddings, or busy seasons like summer on Shelter Island, booking a week or more ahead ensures you get your preferred date and menu options.
The earlier you book, the more time we have to customize your menu and coordinate any special requests like dietary accommodations or specific setup requirements. During peak summer season when Shelter Island hosts more events, earlier booking is especially important.
Do you provide setup and cleanup services for catered events?
Yes, full setup and cleanup is included with our catering services. We arrive early to set up your food stations, serving utensils, and any rental items you’ve requested like tables, chairs, or tents. Our staff handles the entire service process during your event.
After your guests finish eating, we take care of all cleanup including packing up leftover food, clearing serving areas, and removing our equipment. You don’t need to worry about washing dishes or dealing with any mess – we handle everything so you can focus on enjoying your event and spending time with your guests.
Can you accommodate dietary restrictions and special requests?
Absolutely. We work with you to create menus that accommodate vegetarian, gluten-free, and other dietary needs. Since everything we serve is made-to-order, we have the flexibility to modify ingredients and preparation methods for specific requirements.
During our initial consultation, we’ll discuss any dietary restrictions or allergies among your guests. We can create separate platters for different dietary needs or modify our existing menu items. Our chefs are experienced in handling various dietary accommodations while maintaining the quality and taste our catering is known for.
What's included in your BBQ catering service?
Our BBQ catering is a complete service where we bring everything to your location – the grill, all cooking equipment, utensils, and experienced staff to handle the grilling. We arrive early to set up and start cooking fresh on-site, so your guests get hot, freshly grilled food.
The service includes your choice of meats, sides, and accompaniments, plus all serving equipment and cleanup. Our staff handles the entire grilling process and serves your guests directly from the grill. This works especially well for Shelter Island’s outdoor events, waterfront gatherings, and backyard celebrations where fresh-grilled food adds to the atmosphere.
How do you ensure food stays fresh for outdoor Shelter Island events?
We use professional food service equipment including insulated containers, warming trays, and refrigerated units to maintain proper food temperatures throughout your event. For outdoor events, we bring portable equipment specifically designed for maintaining food safety in various weather conditions.
Since we prepare everything made-to-order right before your event or on-site, the food starts at peak freshness. Our staff monitors food temperatures and presentation throughout the event, refreshing items as needed. For longer events, we can schedule multiple service times to ensure everything stays at optimal quality and temperature.
What areas around Shelter Island do you serve?
We provide catering services throughout Shelter Island and the surrounding Long Island areas. Our central Long Island locations allow us to efficiently serve Shelter Island Heights, the North Fork, and other nearby communities with the same quality and service.
Travel and delivery are included in our catering packages for the Shelter Island area. We’re familiar with the local venues, seasonal event patterns, and logistical considerations specific to island events. Our team knows the best routes and timing to ensure your food arrives fresh and our setup happens smoothly, regardless of your specific location on or around Shelter Island.
Local Resources