Catering Fire Island


  • Sassy J. Avatar
    Sassy J.

    I mostly get my breakfast here especially while running late. They have a lot of good food.. salads are fresh... read more  - 12/02/2019

    Carmela G. Avatar
    Carmela G.

    Best bagels in town... Anne always greets you with a smile.  - 12/02/2019

    Dayne G. Avatar
    Dayne G.

    Great place for a solid little breakfast to start your day off right. I had an onion bagel with 2... read more  - 6/23/2020

  • Bill B. Avatar
    Bill B.

    Popular place. Always good bagels, good service, friendly staff, nice sandwich selections, comfortable inside and out. Can get crowded during... read more  - 6/23/2020

    Russell F. Avatar
    Russell F.

    Great food and Great Service. I read some of the reviews. It seems like they're getting better and better over time.  - 6/23/2020

    Jafarul W. Avatar
    Jafarul W.

    Awesome food. Manager keep making sure we enjoy out meal. Outstanding!  - 12/02/2019

  • Mark M. Avatar
    Mark M.

    When I visit my Mom, I always stop here to buy a dozen to take home with me(I live in... read more  - 6/23/2020

    AJ M. Avatar
    AJ M.

    Excellent selection. Great service. Fast. Very large cold case. Quality ingredients. Been going there for years.  - 6/23/2020

    Ali K. Avatar
    Ali K.

    Loved the food. That egg sandwich was perfect after a workout 👌  - 12/02/2019

Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York: Suffolk County’s Premier Food Catering Service

When the people of Fire Island, NY are in need of catering services, who do they call? Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York! 

For years, we’ve been treating Suffolk County to the finest, freshest, and tastiest authentic New York-style bagels and homemade cream cheeses, but we’re so much more than just bagels: we’re also one of the Fire Island area’s premier food catering companies. Whether you’re looking for breakfast catering for a corporate board meeting, lunch catering for a private afternoon affair, or BBQ catering for the ultimate summer party, when you choose Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, you can be sure all of your needs will be met!

Catering to Suffolk County is Our Passion

Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York is regarded as one of the best food catering companies in Suffolk County, NY. Our food is delectable, our service is exceptional, and our prices are extremely affordable. When you choose us for your catering needs, you can have confidence knowing that you will receive nothing short of excellence.

What sets us apart from other catering companies in the Fire Island area? It’s our passion and commitment to excellence. We are truly obsessed with food, and we love sharing our enthusiasm with the people of Suffolk County, NY, which is why we offer premier, full-service catering options. To us, catering is about so much more than just food; it’s an experience. The aroma, the presentation and of course, the flavor… It’s really is a sensory experience, and at Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we’ve mastered that art of preparing, presenting, and serving mouthwatering dishes that will delight the senses.

We use only the freshest ingredients (many of which are locally procured), and we artfully combine them to create traditional and creative dishes that are truly out of this world. The mere sight and scent of our food is mouthwatering, but once you sink your teeth into our cuisine, you’ll know why so many people in the Suffolk County region hail Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York as one of the best caterers in the area.

Catering Options to Suit Every Palate and Every Occasion

At Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we offer catering options that will suit every occasion and every palate. In fact, we offer one of the largest and most unique catering menus in Suffolk County.

Wondering what we serve? Here’s a look at just some of the delicacies that we can treat you and your guests to:

Italian Catering

Our Italian catering menu features an array of traditional Italian fare. Options include:

  • An assortment of pastas, such as stuffed shells, meat lasagna, baked ziti, and penne ala vodka
  • Flavorful meats, poultry, and seafood, including chicken marsala, chicken Francese, stuffed pork loin, and stuffed flounder
  • Heroes, paninis, wraps, and sandwiches made with fresh Italian-style Boar’s Head cold cuts, cheeses, and homemade dipping sauces (our balsamic sun-dried tomato dressing is out of this world!)
  • Freshly Caesar and gorgonzola salads
  • Fresh mozzarella and tomato, served with garlic, basil, extra virgin olive oil, and balsamic drizzle

Breakfast Catering

Whether you’re hosting a business meeting or an early- or mid-morning affair, our breakfast catering options are the perfect way to start the day off right. Options include:

  • A Petite Continental Breakfast, with yogurt and granola parfait, muffins, and croissants
  • Rise and Shine Continental Breakfast, complete with an assortment of our signature bagels, bialys, flagels, and all of the fixings.
  • Spa-Lite Breakfast, perfect for lighter fair or served in combination with any of our other breakfast options.
  • Sunrise Hot Breakfast Buffet which features classic morning favorites, such as scrambled eggs, Challah French toast, buttermilk pancakes, hickory smoked bacon, sausage, and cast-iron skillet home fries
  • Breakfast heroes and wraps

Lunch Catering

We can make everything and anything you need to serve your guests a mouthwatering and filling lunch. Some of our menu items that are perfect for lunch include:

  • An assortment of appetizers, like chips and dips, crudities, quiche, wings, braised baby lamb chops, and baked brie
  • Various types of salads, such as Greek, spinach, chopped, cobb, southwestern, and taco
  • Virtually every type of panini, sandwich, and wrap you can imagine, all made with fresh Boar’s Head cold cuts and cheeses.
  • Homemade salad platters, like classic chicken, cran-apple chicken, traditional tuna, honey mustard tuna, egg salad and so much more!

BBQ Catering

Turn your outdoor event into an affair to remember with our finger-liking good BBQ. You’ll be able to sink your teeth into:

  • Hamburgers
  • Hot dogs
  • BBQ grilled chicken
  • Ribs
  • Corn on the cob
  • Potato and macaroni salad, as well as coleslaw
  • Pickles and olives
  • Super sweet watermelon

Dessert Catering

Treat your guests to the sweetest, most taste bud-tantalizing desserts, including:

  • An assortment of miniature French and Italian pastries
  • A variety of handmade cookies
  • Custom cakes, made in any flavor and any design you can imagine
  • Fresh fruits with sweet dipping sauces
  • A Belgium chocolate fountain with all of the fixings
  • An oversized cannoli stuffed with mini cannoli

Or, opt for our dessert buffet, which features an array of the finest, tastiest, and sweetest treats.

For the Ultimate Catering Experience in Suffolk County, Contact Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York

Whether you’re planning a small, intimate gathering, a corporate event, a holiday dinner, or a special affair, sit back, relax, and let us do the cooking for you! To learn more about our catering services or to start planning your menu, give us a call at 1-866-228-37464 today! At Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we look forward to catering to all of your needs.