Catering Mill Neck

  • Pinal Patel Avatar

    came here from out of town to see what why everyone kept raving about there bagels and sandwiches. THEY COMPLETELY EXCEEDED OUR EXPECTATIONS. I will definitely come back for more! they are worth the wait and time. To top it off, the staff there is so friendly! Great experience.

    Pinal Patel 12/02/2019
    William Krasnov Avatar

    Good service and the best bagels you can find anywhere around

    William Krasnov 12/02/2019
  • Linda Knipfing Avatar

    Always fresh and I love that the sesame seeds or whatever toppings you order are all over the bagel, not just on the top. Our new favorite bagel place.

    Linda Knipfing 12/02/2019
    Carmela Giannico Avatar

    Best bagels in town... Anne always greets you with a smile.

    Carmela Giannico 12/02/2019
  • Sassy Jackson Avatar

    I mostly get my breakfast here especially while running late. They have a lot of good food.. salads are fresh and so is the fruits, homemade yogurts..

    Sassy Jackson 12/02/2019
    Md Wasfi Avatar

    I have been coming here since they opened and I love this place. Friendly staff and the most important thing is their bagels and foods are always fresh. Their home fries and chicken cutlet are my favourite. I definetly recommend this place. Keep up the good work guys ! Oh and they accept cards also !

    Md Wasfi 12/02/2019
  • Ali Khan Avatar

    Loved the food. That egg sandwich was perfect after a workout 👌

    Ali Khan 12/02/2019
    James Rienzo Avatar

    Very helpful in completing my needs and very accommodating to what my requests were.

    James Rienzo 12/02/2019
  • Jafarul Warner Avatar

    Awesome food. Manager keep making sure we enjoy out meal. Outstanding!

    Jafarul Warner 12/02/2019
    Edgar Caal Avatar

    The food is always amazing

    Edgar Caal 12/02/2019
  • Jacqueline Rowe Avatar

    Perfect bagels and quick service. What more could you ask for?

    Jacqueline Rowe 12/02/2019

For the Best Italian Catering in Nassau County, Head to Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York!

At Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we offer more than just the best bagels in Nassau County! We also provide full-service catering services. Whether you’re hosting a bridal shower, a birthday party, a holiday dinner, a Super Bowl party, or any other event, you can count on us to make everyone smile with our incredible catering. 

Experience the Best Italian Catering in Nassau County

What’s the quintessential comfort food? – Italian! Savory sauces, hearty sandwiches, fulfilling pastas, delectable pastries; it’s the ultimate taste bud, make-your-stomach-happy experience! In Nassau County, NY, body else does Italian catering quite like Brendal’s Bakery & Eatery of New York! If you want to make sure your next event is a huge success, treat your guests to a mouthwatering experience with our incredible Italian catering. 

What makes our Mill Neck Italian catering so unique? We use the freshest ingredients (many of which are locally procured) and all of our menu items are made-to-order; you won’t find any pre-made dishes here! Our goal is to pack as much flavor into each and every dish. We use traditional recipes to prepare appetizers, entrees, sandwiches, salads, and desserts that will make your guests feel as if they’ve been transported to Italy! Our clients are always amazed by the authentic tastes, and we’re confident that you and your guests will be, too!

Our Authentic Italian Fare 

At Brendal’s Bakery & Eatery of New York, we offer an incredible selection of classic Italian fare. From appetizers and desserts to sandwiches and pasta dishes, with our Italian catering services, your friends and family will be treated to an amazing gastronomic experience. 

What type of dishes do we serve? Here’s a small sampling of our fresh Italian fare: 

Appetizers and Salads 

  • Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
  • Grilled Vegetable Medley
  • Gorgonzola salad
  • Caesar salad

Paninis, Sandwiches, and Wraps

  • Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, black olives, onions, provolone cheese, and tomato-bacon mayo
  • Roasted portabella mushrooms, fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers, fresh basil, and pesto
  • Cappy ham, Genoa salami, Mortadella, provolone cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, baby spinach, red onions, and mushrooms

Traditional and Specialty Heroes

  • Traditional Italian hero, made with fresh Boar’s Head meats and cheeses
  • Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, fire-roasted tomatoes, and romaine leaves, finished with a drizzle of our own balsamic sun-dried tomato dressing

Boar’s Head Select Cold Cut Platters

  • Choose from an array of fresh Italian-style Boar’s Head Select cold cuts to make your own customized meat and cheese platter, such as Cappy ham, Genoa salami, salami, Gouda, mozzarella, provolone, and so much more

Meats, Poultry, and Seafood

  • Filet mignon 
  • Sausage, peppers, and onions marinara 
  • Chicken marsala
  • Chicken Francese
  • Chicken Margherita
  • Stuffed flounder

Pasta Dishes

  • Pasta with olive oil, garlic, and broccoli
  • Pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage
  • Stuffed shells
  • Meat lasagna
  • Baked ziti
  • Eggplant rollatini
  • Penne ala vodka 


  • An assortment of Italian pastries and cookies, such as cream puffs, Italian biscotti, rainbow cookies, and pignoli cookies
  • An over-the-top, super-sized cannoli, stuffed with mini cannoli 

And that’s just a small sampling of the Italian dishes we offer at Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York. Choose from any of the hand-selected items on our catering menu or create your own customized menu. We’ll work with you to create a creative lunch catering or dinner catering experience that will be sure to leave your guests happy. 

At Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, We’re Passionate About Food

Brendel’s Bagels & Eatery of New York, we’re truly passionate about food and sharing that passion with the people of Mill Neck, NY. To that end, we also offer a variety of other menu options to cater to every palate and every event. In addition to our exceptional Italian fare, we provide: 

Breakfast Catering

Celebrate an early or mid-morning affair with our Petite Continental Breakfast, Rise & Shine Continental Breakfast, Brendel’s Spa-Lite Breakfast, Sunrise Hot Breakfast Buffet, Smoked Fish Presentation, Breakfast Heroes and Wraps, Omelets, and of course, an assortment of the freshest bagels in Nassau County, NY complete with an array of our homemade cream cheeses. 

BBQ Catering 

Planning an outdoor event? Traditional BBQ dishes are the perfect way to bring everyone together. Menu items include all the best barbecue favorites, like hamburgers, hot dogs, BBQ grilled chicken, ribs, and corn on the cob. We serve all the fixings, too, such as our homemade potato and macaroni salads, coleslaw, olive and pickle trays, and the freshest, sweetest watermelon you’ve ever tasted

White Cloth Surf & Turf

Perfect for those elegant affairs, our White Cloth Surf & Turf features a variety of our signature hor d’oeuvres, including BBQ lobster tails, grilled marinated filet mignon, and freshly chopped martini salads, all served butler-style. 

Custom and Interactive Desserts

We make the freshest themed cakes for any event; birthdays, bridal showers, anniversaries, baby showers, graduations, retirement parties. Select the flavors and fillings and we’ll create the most beautiful, delicious cake for your special event. If you really want to wow your guests, consider our Chocolate Fountain, which features warm Belgium chocolate and an assortment of fruits, cakes, pretzels, marshmallows, and more for the ultimate sweet treat. 

Dessert Buffet

Mousse, pastries, cookies, chocolates, Italian and French pastries, fresh fruits, and so much more! Our dessert buffet will be sure to tickle the sweetest tooth. 

A Nassau County Catering Experience Like No Other 

Catering is so much more than food; it’s an experience. With catering services by Brendel’s Bakery & Eatery of New York, you can be sure that your event will have a special touch that will create memories to last a lifetime. 

For your next Mill Neck, NY celebration, holiday gathering, or board meeting, leave the food to Brendel’s! Sit back, relax, and enjoy a Nassau County catering experience like no other! To learn more about our catering services or to discuss your menu, give us a call at 1-866-228-37464 today! We look to filling all of your occasions with great food and exceptional service.